we find in tareekh islam; by dhabi, let us first see the scans

so, dhabi says in this that

ahmad bin mohammad bin hussein heard from tehrani who is famous thiqa who heard from abdur raziq  from moamar

from zuhri from urwa from ayesha from abu bakar who said i heard holy prophet asws saying looking at face of ali asws is ibadat,

this is written by as-saman in his book al-mawafiqah from ibn-ul-haj AND abi ali bin mehdi who heard from him

[tareekh-e-islam, vol 7, page 872, in the history of those who died in 349 hijri]

so the chain which we get here is

as saman-ibn ul haj-ahmad bin mohammad-tehrani-abdur raziq-moamar-zuhri-urwa-ayesha-abu bakar-holy prophet asws

let us analyze the chain

AS-SAMAN

his name is abu saad ismail ibn ali ibn hussein as saman

dhabi introduced him in his book sair ul alam nabala

السمان الامام الحافظ العلامة البارع المتقن ابو سعد ، إسماعيل بن علي بن الحسين

as-saman imam, hafiz, allama, master, exquisite abu saad ismail bin ali bin hussein

[sair ul alam nabala, vol 18, page 55-56, narrator 26, heading AS-SAMAN]

IBN UL HAJ

he is ahmad bin mohammad bin haj, abu abbas, as shabeli

dhabi writes about him in sair ul alam nabala

ابن الحاج الامام المحدث الثقة، أبو العباس، أحمد بن محمد بن الحاج

ibn ul haj, imam, mohadith, thiqa, abu abbas, ahmad bin mohammad bin haj

[sair ul alam, vol 17, page 329, no. 201, heading ibn ul haj]


AHMAD BIN MOHAMMAD BIN HUSSEIN

this is where we started from, dhabi says about him in sair ul alam

السندي الشيخ الكبير مسند وقته ابو الفوارس احمد بن محمد بن الحسين بن السندي المصري الصابوني

sindi, he is great sheikh, musnad of his time, abu fawaris sindi

[sair, vol 15, page 541, narrator 320, heading of AL-SINDI]

dhabi further added on the next page

وهو صدوق في نفسه

he was truthful in himself

but dhabi could not hide his nasibiat here, and he said that he was truthful but entered a batil hadeeth

and then he gave the sanad we are talking about

but dhabi forgot that he is himself praising those who are in the chain

that is what is called

jhoot ka paon nahi hotay

lie has no feet to stand upon

anyways, let us come back to the sanad

MOHAMMAD BIN HAMAD TEHRANI


dhabi himself said that he is famous thiqa, if you see the scan above

ibn hajar said about him

[176] ق بن ماجة محمد بن حماد الطهراني أبو عبد الله الحافظ الرازي

and then he gave opinions

قال بن أبي حاتم سمعت منه مع أبي بالري وببغداد والإسكندرية وهو صدوق ثقة وقال بن خراش كان عدلا ثقة وقال الدارقطني ثقة وذكره بن حبان في الثقات وقال أبو سعيد بن يونس كان من أهل الرحلة في طلب الحديث وكان ثقة صاحب حديث

ABDUR RAZIQ BIN HAMAM


Abdur raziq bin hamam, abu bakar as-sanani,

dhabi says about him in sair alam

عبد الرزاق بن همام ع ابن نافع الحافظ الكبير عالم اليمن أبو بكر الحميري مولاهم الصنعاني الثقة

grand hafiz, scholar of yemen, thiqa


MOAMAR BIN RASHID

Dhabi said about him in sair

معمر بن راشد ع

الإمام الحافظ شيخ الإسلام أبو عروة بن أبي عمرو الأزدي

moamar bin rashid, imam, hafiz, sheikh of islam

ZUHRI

his name is mohammad bin muslim bin shahab zuhri,

dhabi says about him in sair

محمد بن مسلم بن عبيد الله بن عبد الله بن شهاب بن عبد الله بن الحارث بن زهرة بن كلاب بن مرة بن كعب بن لؤي بن غالب

الإمام العلم حافظ زمانه أبو بكر القرشي الزهري

he gives the full name and then says

imam of knowledge, hafiz of the time


URWA BIN ZUBAIR

Dhabi said about him in sair

عروة ابن حواري رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم وابن عمته صفية الزبير بن العوام بن خويلد بن أسد بن عبد العزى بن قصي بن كلاب

الإمام عالم المدينة أبو عبد الله القرشي الأسدي المدني الفقيه أحد الفقهاء

urwa son of hawari of prophet asws……. imam, scholar of madina,……. faqih one of fuqaha


then is ayesha, and followed by abu bakar

i have tried to quote the work of dhabi, because in sair alam, he said that the hadeeth is munkar, and i wanted to show that he is a perfect nasibi, who is willing to go to any extent to prove that this glory does not exist for mola ali asws

we already talked of his nasibiat in the post where we showed his grudge while doing talkess of hakim’s mustadarak

Advertisements