this is the fifth post in this series, and here we will discuss this hadeeth which says that prophet asws would teach mola ali asws, i am quoting it from online version of khasais-e-ali, hadeeth 114


( أخبرنا ) احمد بن شعيب ، قال : اخبرنا محمد بن بشار ، قال : حدثني أبو المساور ، قال : حدثنا عوف عن عبد الله بن

عمرو بن هند الجملي ، عن علي رضي الله عنه قال : كنت إذا سألت رسول الله صلى الله عليه وآله أعطيت ، وإذا سكت

ابتدأني

auf bin abdullah said that i heard ali sayiing: when i asked, holy prophet asws gave me; and when i kept quiet, he started

.

REFERENCES:-

.

1- al mustadarak, vol 3, page 125

2-jami tirmidhi, vol 5, page 301, narration 3805

3-masnad tayalsi, vol 1, page 149

4-fadail us sahaba, vol 2, page 706, narration 1099

5-khasais-e-ali, page 111, narration 116

6- tabaqat kubra, vol 2, page 338

7-musanif ibn abi sheebah, vol 7, page 495, narration 6

8- sunan kubra nisai; vol 5, page 142

9- tareekh madina damishq, vol 42, page 277

.

OPINIONS OF SCHOLARS:-

.

1- hakim: hadeeth is sahih as per condition of sheikhain but they did not write it

2-dhabi: on the condition of bukhari and muslim

[mustadarak, vol 3, page 125]

3-tirmidhi: hasan ghareeb

[jami tirmidhi, vol 5, page 301,3805]

4-wasi ullah bin mohammad abbass: isnaad sahih

[fadail us sahaba, vol 2, page 706, narration 1099]

5- mohammad bin abdulmohsin turki: hadeeth sahih

[masnad abu daood tayalsi, vol 1. page 149, narration 176]

6-shoiab ul arnawit; narrators are thiqa

[ taleeq ala sair ul aalam nabala, vol 1, page 541 and vol 2, page 388]

7- baghwi mentioned it in hasan category

[masabeeh us sunnah, vol 4, page 174, narration 4771, kitab manaqib, book manaqib ali]

8-dia ul moqadasi said:isnaad sahih

[al ahadeeth ul mukhtara, vol 2, page 235, narration 641]

Advertisements