Efendi al- in his full of false blog wrote:

Majlisi in “Buharul anwar” (27/32-33) narrated from Samaah ibn Mihran:
قال: كنت عند أبي عبد الله عليه السلام فأرعدت السماء وأبرقت، فقال أبو عبدالله عليه السلام: أما إنه ما كان من هذا الرعد ومن هذا البرق فانه من أمر صاحبكم،قلت: من صاحبنا ؟ قال: أمير المؤمنين عليه السلام
I was near Abu Abdullah (alaihi salam) when sky covered with clouds and (we heard) the burst of the thunder. He said: “That’s thunder and lightning are from your companion”. We asked:”Who is that?” Imam replied: “Amirulmuminin (alaihi salam).


This nasibi is rijal fanatic and rijal gambler. But when he post shia hadiths just don’t want to do his “lovely job”.

And I come to a conclusion that he is masochist, he likes when somebody destroy his false articles. I can not call this act otherwise. If somebody can, please help.

Let’s look at the full narration with its chain.

ختص: المعلى عن سليمان بن سماعة عن _عبد الله بن القاسم_ عن سماعة بن مهران قال: كنت عند أبي عبد الله عليه السلام فأرعدت السماء وأبرقت، فقال أبو عبد الله عليه السلام:أما إنه ما كان من هذا الرعد ومن هذا البرق فانه من أمر صاحبكم، قلت: من صاحبنا ؟ قال: أمير المؤمنين عليه السلام

Narrator Abdullah b. al-Qasim is extreamly weak and liar.

1. Liar, ghulat, narrates from/about the extremists, no good in him

Rijal an-Najashi, p.226, #594

2. He is waqifi.

Rijal at-Toosi, p. 341, #5089

3. Liar, ghulat, his narrations are unacceptable

Tartib khulaṣat al-aqwal fi ma‘rifat ilm al-rijal, Allamah Hilli p.237

4. Liar, ghulat, narrates from/about the extremists, no good in him

Rijal ibn Dawud, p.255

5. Liar, ghal, narrates from ghulat.

Tafarshi, Naqd al-Rijal, v.3, p.131, #3168

[contributed by brother master_ier]

Advertisements