ibn Hajar writes in his book “Tabqat ul Modaliseen”

23 – ق س محمد بن إسماعيل بن إبراهيم بن المغيرة البخاري الامام وصفه بذلك أبو عبد الله بن مندة في كلام له فقال فيه اخرج البخاري قال فلان وقال لنا فلان وهو تدليس ولم يوافق بن مندة على ذلك والذي يظهر أنه يقول فيما لم يسمع وفيما سمع لكن لا يكون على شرطه أو موقوفا قال لي أو قال لنا وقد عرفت ذلك بالاستقراء من صنيعه


Mohammad bin Ismail bin Ibrahim bin Mughaira al Bukhari Imam, Abu Abdullah bin Mundah characterized Him in His Work that Bukhari said :Fulan said;; or Bukhari said: Fulan told us;; And this is Tadless; and ibn Mundah did not agree to that; And what is Apparent is that He said when He did not hear or He heard but it was not on His condition or he was staying/taking precautions He told me or He told us; and I know this by reading His work

[Tabqat ul Mudaliseen, vol 1, page 24]

Advertisements