taken from urdu article of brother hasan molai

we find in khasais-e-ali by nisai

HADEETH 99:-

( أخبرنا ) احمد بن شعيب ، قال : اخبرنا اسماعيل بن مسعود البصري ، قال : حدثنا شعبة ، عن ابي اسحاق ، عن العلاء : سأل رجل ابن عمر عن عثمان قال : كان من الذين تولوا يوم التقى الجمعان فتاب الله عليه ثم اصاب ذنبا فقتله . فسأله عن علي رضي الله عنه فقال : لا تسأل عنه ألا ترى منزلته من رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم ( 4 ) .

A’ala bin a’arar narrates that a man came to ask ibn umar about uthman; so he said

“he was amongst those who ran away on day fo uhud; but allah forgave him. Then he made mistake, so you killed him.

He asked about ali; and he replied “do not ask about him, did you not see his status near prophet”


HADEETH 100

( أخبرنا ) احمد بن شعيب ، قال : اخبرنا هلال بن العلاء عن عرار ( 5 ) انه قال : سألت عبد الله بن عمر قلت : ألا تحدثني عن علي وعثمان ؟ قال : أما علي فهذا بيته من بيت رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم ولا احدثك عنه بغيره ، وأما عثمان : فانه أذنب يوم احد ذنبا عظيما

عفى الله عنه ، واذنب فيكم ذنبا صغيرا فقتلتموه ( 1 ) .

A’aala narrates that I asked Abdullah bin umar

“why do you not tell me about ali and uthman?”

he said

“regarding ali, his house is loved by prophet, and I will not tell you more about him; as regards to uthman, he made a big mistake on the day of uhud, and allah forgave him; and he made a smaller mistake, and you killed him”

HADEETH 101:-

( أخبرنا ) أحمد بن شعيب ، قال : اخبرنا احمد بن سليمان الرهاوي ، قال : حدثنا عبد الله ، قال : أخبرنا اسرائيل ، عن ابي اسحاق عن العلاء بن العرار قال : سألت عن ذلك ابن عمر وهو في مسجد رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم قال : ما في المسجد بيت غير بيته ، وأما عثمان فانه اذنب ذنبا دون ذلك فقتلتموه ( 2 )

A’ala narrates that I asked Abdullah bin umar regarding uthman and ali, and he was in mosque of prophet asws; so he said

“do not ask about ali, look at his house which is one of the homes of prophet, and there is not home except his in mosque; as regards to uthman, he made a huge mistake on uhud, he ran away on uhud, but allah forgave him; then he made a mistake, and you killed him”

chains have been authenticated by sunni scholars and can be seen in online reference ; however other references can also be seen here

narration tells us three things 

1- uthman ran away from uhud
2- ibn umar accepted that uthman did a major and minor sin
3- uthman got killed because of a mistake he made; can a person be called martyr because he was killed due to his mistake?

may allah give happiness of both world to brother hasan molai and give him the strength to serve masoomen
amin

Advertisements