A question was asked from Dar-ul-Ifta Deoband, as to what should be the stance regarding fights between Imam Ali (asws) & Ayesha, and Mawia. So they replied, as usual that, One should keep quiet regarding that, since it is strictly prohibited as per Narrations of Holy Prophet (asws) & He narrated that Be fearful about my Companions from Allah, and do not target them with speech which is not liked. They argued with the Narration

اللّٰہ اللّٰہ في أصحابي لا تتخذوھم غرضا من بعدي الحدیث (مشکاة، ص:۵۵۴) میرے صحابہ کرام کے سلسلہ میں اللہ سے ڈرو، اللہ سے ڈرو، میرے بعد ان کو اپنے ناپسندیدہ کلام کے لیے نشانہ مت بناوٴ۔

They quoted Mishkat. When we refer to that book, 3/309, we find that It is taken from Tirmidhi. 

وعن عبد الله بن مغفل قال : قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم : ” الله الله في أصحابي لا تتخذوهم غرضا من بعدي فمن أحبهم فبحبي أحبهم ومن أبغضهم فببغضي أبغضهم ومن آذاهم فقد آذاني ومن آذاني فقد آذى الله ومن آذى الله فيوشك أن يأخذه ” . رواه الترمذي وقال : هذا حديث غريب

 

This narration has been included in Daif Sunan Tirmidhi, p. 442, Hadeeth No. 3862; by Sheikh Albany

Also, Albany included this narration in his Silsila Ahadeeth Daifiyya, 6/443, Hadeeth No. 2901

 

This, in simple words mean, that Deobandi fatwa centre tried to deceive its readers by quoting a Daif/Weak Narration. 

 

lie

Advertisements